Lake County Criminal Defense Attorneys

Are You in Need of a Lake County Criminal Defense Lawyer?

Whether you’re a resident or a visitor who found yourself in trouble while in Colorado, we’re here to protect your rights, your reputation, and your future.

When you’re charged with a crime in Lake County, your future and freedom are on the line. You need more than just legal advice; you need a team that knows the local courts, understands how prosecutors think, and is ready to fight for you from day one.

At Whitaker & Penix, LLC, we provide a strong, practical defense for individuals facing criminal charges in Lake County and the surrounding mountain communities. As former prosecutors, our attorneys know what it takes to dismantle a criminal case.

Even minor offenses can have major impacts. A criminal conviction can affect employment, housing, your ability to travel, and even child custody or professional licensing. From the moment you contact us, we begin working to protect your rights and develop a strategy that serves your best interests.

Why Choose Us Over Other Criminal Defense Lawyers in Lake County?

At Whitaker & Penix, LLC, we’re not a large, high-volume firm where cases get handed off or lost in the shuffle. When you hire us, you get direct access to your attorney and a defense team that knows your case inside and out. Here’s why people in Lake County have come to trust our criminal defense firm:

• A+ Rating from the Better Business Bureau: Our firm maintains the highest possible BBB rating, reflecting our commitment to integrity, professionalism, and client satisfaction.
• BBB Accreditation with a Longstanding Record of Trust: We have earned the BBB’s accreditation for consistent ethical practices and exceptional client service throughout the mountain region.
• Kylie Whitaker Recognized as a Colorado Rising Star by Super Lawyers: Kylie’s inclusion on the Super Lawyers list is a testament to her reputation, skill, and proven results in the courtroom.
• Former Prosecutors With Real Trial Experience: Both founding attorneys previously served as prosecutors, giving us valuable insight into how criminal cases are investigated, charged, and tried in Lake County courts.
• Clear Communication and Responsiveness: Our clients appreciate that we return calls, answer questions promptly, and stay in touch even after hours when urgent issues arise.
• Serving Clients Across Colorado’s 5th and 6th Judicial Districts: We represent locals and visitors alike, offering trusted, experienced legal representation across the Colorado high country.

Call for a Free Consultation

Just dial (970) 368-0602 for experienced criminal defense representation from Whitaker & Penix, LLC.

What to Do If You Get Arrested

If you’re arrested in Lake County, your first priority should be to remain calm and avoid saying anything that could harm your case. Many people make the mistake of trying to explain themselves to police officers, only to have their words used against them later.

Follow these steps immediately:

1. Stay calm and respectful. Do not resist arrest or argue with law enforcement.
2. Exercise your right to remain silent. Anything you say can be used against you.
3. Request an attorney. Politely but firmly state that you will not answer questions without a lawyer present.
4. Contact Whitaker & Penix, LLC as soon as possible. The earlier we’re involved, the better we can protect your rights and guide your next steps.

Cases We Handle

Our attorneys represent clients facing a wide range of criminal charges in Lake County. From misdemeanors and traffic offenses to serious felonies, we treat every case with the focus and determination it deserves.

We build strong defenses, uncover weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome, whether that means reduced charges, alternative sentencing, or full acquittal at trial.

Felonies

Felony charges are among the most serious criminal accusations under Colorado law. They can carry years of prison time, hefty fines, and long-lasting consequences such as the loss of voting rights or firearm ownership.

We defend clients facing felony allegations including burglary, assault, theft, drug trafficking, and other major offenses. Every detail matters in these cases, and we prepare as if each one is going to trial. Our focus is always on building a complete and strategic defense designed to protect your freedom and future.

Assault

Assault charges can arise from heated arguments, bar fights, or even self-defense situations that are misunderstood by law enforcement. These cases often hinge on perspective, witness credibility, and the interpretation of evidence.

We work to uncover the full story, present evidence that supports your version of events, and challenge exaggerated or false claims. Whether the charge is simple assault, aggravated assault, or a domestic-related offense, we will ensure your rights are upheld and your side is heard.

DUI Defense

DUI arrests are common in mountain communities like Lake County, where law enforcement is especially vigilant about impaired driving. A DUI conviction can lead to jail time, license suspension, costly fines, and increased insurance rates.

At Whitaker & Penix, LLC, we understand how to evaluate the evidence in DUI cases. That means scrutinizing the details about the traffic stops, field sobriety test procedures, and breath or blood test results. We represent locals and tourists who are facing DUI charges and will fight to minimize penalties or seek dismissal whenever possible.

Traffic Violations

Traffic offenses may seem minor, but repeated violations or certain infractions can result in license suspension, large fines, or even jail time. We represent clients facing charges such as reckless driving, careless driving, excessive speeding, and driving without insurance.

Our goal is to protect your driving record, prevent increased insurance costs, and keep you on the road. For out-of-state visitors charged with traffic offenses while vacationing in the area, we can often appear in court on your behalf.

Drug Crimes

Colorado’s drug laws remain complex and heavily enforced, especially in rural areas. Charges can range from misdemeanor possession to felony distribution or manufacturing.

We handle all types of drug-related cases, including those involving controlled substances, prescription medications, or marijuana. Our background as former prosecutors gives us insight into how these cases are investigated, allowing us to identify weaknesses in the state’s evidence, challenge unlawful searches, and negotiate favorable outcomes.

Domestic Violence

Domestic violence allegations can arise from emotional, complicated situations. In Colorado, police are required to make an arrest if they believe probable cause exists, even if no physical injury occurred.

A domestic violence charge can lead to protective orders, mandatory counseling, and damage to your personal and professional reputation. We understand the sensitive nature of these cases and work discreetly to protect your rights, uncover the truth, and limit the impact on your life.

Charged with a Crime? Don’t Wait to Get Help

Call (970) 368-0602 today for a free consultation with a local defense attorney.

The Legal Process When Someone Is Arrested

Understanding what happens after an arrest can make a stressful situation more manageable. Here’s what you can generally expect:

1. Arrest and Booking – You’ll be taken into custody, photographed, fingerprinted, and officially charged.
2. Bond or Bail – In many cases, you may be eligible for release on bond. We can argue for a fair bond amount or for release on personal recognizance.
3. Arraignment – You will appear before a judge who will inform you of your charges and rights. At this stage, we enter a plea and begin the defense process.
4. Pre-Trial Motions and Discovery – We exchange evidence with the prosecution, file motions to suppress illegally obtained evidence, and work to weaken the state’s case.
5. Negotiation and Plea Discussions – If a resolution can be reached that serves your interests, we will negotiate skillfully for reduced charges or alternative sentencing.
6. Trial – If your case proceeds to trial, we are ready. As experienced litigators, we prepare each case as if it will go before a jury to ensure you have the strongest possible defense.
7. Sentencing (if applicable) – If convicted, we continue to advocate for you, arguing for the lowest possible penalties and exploring options such as probation or diversion programs.

How a Lawyer Can Help

A criminal defense attorney is more than just a legal representative. They’re your advocate, your voice, and your protection in a system designed to convict. At Whitaker & Penix, LLC, we provide hands-on, strategic representation for every client.

Here’s how we can help you:

• Thorough Case Investigation – We dig into every detail, review police reports, interview witnesses, and uncover inconsistencies in the prosecution’s story.
• Challenging Evidence and Arrests – If police violated your rights or obtained evidence unlawfully, we move to have it excluded from your case.
• Negotiating for Reduced Charges – Our background as former prosecutors allows us to negotiate effectively with the state, often achieving outcomes others can’t.
• Court Representation and Trial Defense – We handle every hearing, file every motion, and present your defense before the judge or jury with skill and preparation.
• Personal Support and Communication – You’ll always know what’s happening in your case, what to expect next, and how to make informed decisions.
• Fighting for Your Future – Whether through dismissal, acquittal, or reduced penalties, our goal is to protect your freedom and help you move forward.

Speak With a Trusted Lake County Criminal Defense Lawyer

If you’ve been arrested or charged with a crime in Lake County, you don’t have to face it alone. At Whitaker & Penix, LLC, we combine trial experience, local knowledge, and personalized service to provide strong and effective legal defense.

Call (970) 368-0602 today to schedule a free consultation. We’re ready to help you protect your rights and take back control of your future.

What Clients Are Saying About Us

I’m thankful I worked with her - Marijah Wilson (5-Star Google Review)

Kylie has years of experience and thorough knowledge of the law. She was always available to answer my questions and concerns. She always answered my calls or responded to me in a timely manner. She put me at ease while also being very honest about all the possibilities and legalities. She would take the time and go into detail when I didn’t understand something. She’s personable and understanding, which made me feel safe throughout the process, and I’m thankful I worked with her.

I would recommend Ehren Penix any day - Rick Sexton (5-Star Google Review)

Awesome. I have been involved with the legal system a few times and [can] say, hands down, this was the best experience I have ever had. Very thorough, thoughtful, concise, and an absolute Pitbull when needed. I would recommend Ehren Penix any day in any circumstance. Really impressive. Thanks again, Ehren.

Criminal Defense Lawyer FAQs

What should I do if I’m arrested in Colorado?

If you’re arrested, stay calm, remain polite, and exercise your right to remain silent. Do not answer any questions until you have spoken with an attorney. Politely tell the officer that you want a lawyer present before continuing the conversation. Then contact Whitaker & Penix, LLC at (970) 368-0602 right away so we can begin protecting your rights.

Do I really need a criminal defense lawyer?

Yes. Even seemingly minor charges can have serious long-term consequences. A lawyer ensures that your rights are protected, negotiates with prosecutors, challenges weak evidence, and helps you avoid common mistakes that could harm your case.

Can you represent out-of-state visitors charged in Colorado?

Absolutely. Many of our clients are tourists or seasonal visitors who are arrested while vacationing in Breckenridge, Leadville, or other mountain communities. We often appear in court on your behalf and manage your case locally, minimizing your need to travel back to Colorado.

What are the penalties for a DUI in Colorado?

DUI penalties can include license suspension, fines, mandatory alcohol education, community service, and possible jail time, and the consequences become more severe with repeat offenses. We review every aspect of your arrest to challenge improper stops, field tests, or chemical test procedures.

What’s the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor in Colorado?

A felony is a serious criminal charge that can result in state prison time, while a misdemeanor typically carries shorter jail terms, probation, or fines. However, both can leave you with a permanent record. We handle both types of cases and work to reduce or dismiss charges whenever possible.

What if I was charged with domestic violence but my partner doesn’t want to press charges?

In Colorado, the decision to pursue a domestic violence case lies with the prosecutor, not the alleged victim. Even if the accuser changes their mind, the state can still proceed. Our attorneys help navigate this complex process and fight to protect your record, rights, and relationships.

How soon should I contact a lawyer after being charged?

Immediately. The earlier you hire a Lake County attorney, the more opportunities we have to gather evidence, protect your rights, and negotiate with prosecutors. Quick action often leads to better outcomes, such as reduced charges or dismissal before your case escalates.

Meet Out Attorneys

Kylie Whitaker

Kylie Whitaker is a founding attorney at Whitaker & Penix, LLC, where she provides trusted, results-oriented legal representation in both criminal defense and personal injury matters throughout Summit County, Lake County, and the surrounding mountain communities. With over a decade of courtroom experience, including seven years as a criminal prosecutor, Kylie brings a powerful combination of trial skill, legal insight, and compassion to every case she handles.

Before co-founding the firm, Kylie served as an Assistant District Attorney in Breckenridge, where she prosecuted hundreds of criminal cases ranging from DUIs and assaults to serious felonies. This experience gave her a deep understanding of how local prosecutors approach cases and what strategies are most effective in securing favorable results for defendants.

Ehren Penix

Ehren Penix is a founding attorney at Whitaker & Penix, LLC, where he represents clients throughout Summit and Lake Counties in both criminal defense and personal injury matters. Known for his calm professionalism, strong courtroom presence, and commitment to client communication, Ehren approaches every case with thorough preparation and a deep understanding of Colorado law.

Before entering private practice, Ehren served as a criminal prosecutor, giving him firsthand insight into how the state investigates and prosecutes cases. That experience now gives him an advantage as a defense attorney by allowing him to anticipate the prosecution’s strategies, identify weaknesses in their arguments, and build strong, strategic defenses for his clients.